105 Sylvar Street

The Willey House at 105 Sylvar Street in Santa Cruz, is a historically designated Victorian residence set behind a canopy of mature trees on Santa Cruzs historic Mission Plaza. This iconic property blends timeless Stick-Eastlake architecture with rich local heritage and enduring character. Originally built in 1887 for Henry Willey, the first president of Peoples Bank, this distinguished 3,698 square foot residence showcases unparalleled craftsmanship. Expertly constructed from locally harvested old-growth heart redwood, the 6-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom residence stands as a testament to enduring quality. Every corner of the home tells a story, from its intricate woodwork, detailed stained glass, and steeply pitched rooflines to the inviting wrap-around porch and period detailing throughout. Tall windows flood the interior with natural light, highlighting soaring, vaulted ceilings, original millwork, and elegant living spaces designed for both entertaining and everyday living. The home offers City Views and an excellent Walk Score, making it a highly convenient commute location. The property also features a legal detached ADU with a dedicated separate entrance and private yard space that currently generates substantial income, providing financial flexibility and additional value.

Days on Market

1 day

Current Status

Active

Original Price

$2,495,000

List Price

$2,495,000

On Market Date

May 20, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Home

Area

43 - West Santa Cruz

Zip Code

95060

MLS ID

ML82048077

APN

006-172-08-000

Year Built

1873

Stories in Building

Unavailable

Possession

Unavailable

Data Source

MLSL

Origin MLS System

MLSListings, Inc.

Bed

6

Bath

4

Stall Shower, Tile, Showers over Tubs - 2+

Parking

3

Off-Street Parking, On Street, Parking Area

SQ FT

3,698

SQ FT Source

Unavailable

Lot SQ FT

6,752.0

Lot Acres

0.155005 Acres

Pool Info

Spa / Hot Tub

Kitchen

Dishwasher, Cooktop - Gas, Garbage Disposal, Microwave, Exhaust Fan, Refrigerator

Cooling

Whole House / Attic Fan, Ceiling Fan

Dining Room

Formal Dining Room

Disclosures

Lead Base Disclosure, Natural Hazard Disclosure

Family Room

Separate Family Room

Flooring

Tile, Hardwood

Foundation

Crawl Space, Masonry Perimeter, Post and Pier, Raised

Fire Place

Free Standing, Gas Burning, Insert, Living Room, Other Location

Heating

Central Forced Air, Fireplace

Laundry

Washer / Dryer, Tub / Sink, In Utility Room

Views

Hills, Park, Neighborhood, City Lights, Garden / Greenbelt

Architectural Style

Victorian

Fee

Unavailable

MLS and other Information regarding properties for sale as shown in Theo have been obtained from various sources such as sellers, public records, agents and other third parties. This information may relate to the condition of the property, permitted or unpermitted uses, zoning, square footage, lot size/acreage or other matters affecting value or desirability. Unless otherwise indicated in writing, neither brokers, agents nor Theo have verified, or will verify, such information. If any such information is important to buyer in determining whether to buy, the price to pay or intended use of the property, buyer is urged to conduct their own investigation with qualified professionals, satisfy themselves with respect to that information, and to rely solely on the results of that investigation.

School data provided by GreatSchools. School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.